Section 230: Why Websites Don’t Have to Remove User Posts (and the Exceptions)

Need Harmful Content Removed Legally?

We help individuals and businesses use the law to take back control online. DMCA, GDPR, and legal notices all handled by experts. Request a confidential case review today.

Quick answer

Section 230, codified at 47 U.S.C. § 230, limits when a website or user can be treated as responsible for content posted by someone else. Subsection (c)(1) says that "no provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider." It does not require a website to remove a post, and it does not guarantee removal.

Section 230 is a liability rule, not a removal process. Subsection (e) lists exceptions for federal criminal law, intellectual property law, the Electronic Communications Privacy Act and certain sex trafficking claims. Outcomes depend on platform policies, applicable law, content eligibility and supporting evidence.

What is Section 230 and what does it cover

What is Section 230 and what does it cover?

Section 230 is part of Title II of the Communications Act of 1934, and its core protection sits in subsection (c)(1). Congress added it on February 8, 1996, as section 509 of title V of Public Law 104-104. Title V may be cited as the Communications Decency Act of 1996.

Under the statute’s definitions, an "interactive computer service" is any information service, system or access software provider that enables computer access by multiple users to a computer server (subsection (f)(2)). A forum or comment section can fit that description. Whether a particular site does is a question for an expert or the court.

What does platform liability mean under Section 230?

Platform liability means whether a provider or user can be treated as the publisher or speaker of what someone else posted. Subsection (c)(1) bars that treatment for information "provided by another information content provider."

Two limits follow from the wording. Under subsection (f)(3), an information content provider is anyone "responsible, in whole or in part, for the creation or development" of information. On that wording, content a platform creates or develops itself falls outside the phrase "provided by another." Subsection (c)(1) also does not say who is responsible for a person’s own post. That question depends on the claim and the court.

Hypothetical: a forum user posts a false accusation about a neighbor. The neighbor asks the forum to remove it, and the forum refuses. Subsection (c)(1) is the provision the forum would cite against being treated as the publisher of that post. The neighbor’s claim against the original poster is a separate question.

Do websites have to remove user posts under Section 230?

No. Section 230 does not itself require a website to remove a user post. Subsection (c)(1) bars treating a provider or user as publisher, and it contains no removal requirement. Subsection (c)(2) describes restricting material as an action taken "voluntarily."

Removal can still happen through the platform’s own policies, a court order or another legal process. Whether any of these works depends on platform policy, applicable law, content eligibility and the evidence available.

Which claims does Section 230 not cover?

Subsection (e) says Section 230 has no effect on federal criminal law, intellectual property law, communications privacy law or certain sex trafficking claims. Its rule for state law is in (e)(3).

Subsection What the text says
(e)(1) Federal criminal law Does not impair enforcement of section 223 or 231, chapter 71 or 110 of title 18, or any other federal criminal statute.
(e)(2) Intellectual property Does not limit or expand any law pertaining to intellectual property.
(e)(3) State law Does not stop a state from enforcing a state law consistent with the section. No liability may be imposed under inconsistent state or local law.
(e)(4) Communications privacy Does not limit the Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 or similar state law.
(e)(5) Sex trafficking Does not impair a civil claim under 18 U.S.C. § 1595 where the conduct would violate 18 U.S.C. § 1591, or certain state criminal charges tied to § 1591 or § 2421A.

Copyright claims follow a separate process. Subsection (e)(2) leaves intellectual property law as it is, and copyright notices use the process in 17 U.S.C. § 512. Under § 512(c)(3), a notification must be a written communication to the service provider’s designated agent. It must identify the copyrighted work and the material, include a statement of good-faith belief, and carry a signature. For the legal steps, see legal removal request options.

How does good-faith moderation work under Section 230(c)(2)

How does good-faith moderation work under Section 230(c)(2)?

Section 230(c)(2)(A) protects a provider or user from liability for action "voluntarily taken in good faith" to restrict material it considers obscene, lewd, filthy, excessively violent, harassing or otherwise objectionable. The protection applies whether or not the material is constitutionally protected. The subsection does not require any removal.

The section does not define good faith. How a court judges it depends on the facts and the jurisdiction. In practice, a platform’s content policy usually decides what it removes, and Section 230 protects that choice from certain liability.

What is the difference between removal, de-indexing, suppression and review disputes?

Removal means the content is deleted or hidden on the site where it appears. De-indexing means the page is removed from a search index, under that search engine’s own process. Suppression means lawful ranking or visibility work that makes content less prominent, with no removal guarantee. A review dispute is a request made under the review platform’s own policy.

Each route has different rules and different limits on outcomes.

What should you do when Section 230 blocks a claim?

Save the evidence, read the platform’s policy, and check the claim against subsection (e) before deciding what to do next. Whether the statute applies depends on the claim itself.

  1. Save the URLs, screenshots and dates. Your record supports every later step.
  2. Read the platform’s policy for that content type. The platform’s policy often decides what it will remove.
  3. Check the claim against subsection (e). Note whether it falls in one of the listed areas.
  4. Check whether a court order route applies. See court order to remove content from internet for the basics.
  5. Request a confidential case review for a case-specific assessment.

Which other removal routes can apply when Section 230 does not?

Court orders, defamation claims and review and report sites can apply when Section 230 does not, and each has its own rules.

  • Court orders: A court can order removal in some cases. Whether one is available depends on the case and the court.
  • Legal removal requests: A formal request under the law or policy that fits the claim. The outcome depends on the claim, the platform and the evidence.
  • Defamatory content: A defamation claim depends on the statement and the law of the place where the claim is brought. Read remove defamatory content.
  • Review and report sites: These follow their own policies. Read ripoff report removal.

Frequently asked questions about Section 230

Does Section 230 require websites to remove user posts?

No. Subsection (c)(1) limits liability and contains no removal requirement. Removal depends on platform policy, applicable law and evidence.

Does Section 230 protect platforms from copyright claims?

No. Subsection (e)(2) says the section neither limits nor expands intellectual property law. Copyright removal uses the notice process in 17 U.S.C. § 512.

Does Section 230 protect against federal criminal charges?

No. Subsection (e)(1) says nothing in the section impairs enforcement of federal criminal statutes.

Can a website remove a post voluntarily under Section 230(c)(2)?

Yes. Subsection (c)(2)(A) protects good-faith action to restrict objectionable material, but the section does not require it.

Does Section 230 protect the original poster?

No, not for content they provided themselves. Subsection (c)(1) covers information provided by another, and responsibility for a person’s own post depends on the claim and the court.

Can Section 230 be used to get a post removed?

No. It limits liability for platforms and users, and it is not a removal tool.

Is removal guaranteed if a claim is not barred by Section 230?

No. Removal depends on platform policy, applicable law, content eligibility and evidence.

Does Section 230 cover search result de-indexing?

No. It is not a tool for removing search results. De-indexing follows the search engine’s own process, and no outcome is guaranteed.

Can a confidential case review help with a Section 230 problem?

Yes, a confidential case review can give a case-specific assessment, though it cannot promise a result. Internet Content Removal advertises a free case review. The assessment looks at platform policies, applicable law, content eligibility and supporting evidence.

Send your URLs, dates and screenshots to start a confidential case review and find out which routes fit your situation.

Take back control of your online presence get harmful content removed today.

📞 Free Case Review | 💼 Confidential & Legal-Backed Solutions

Contact Us

Fill out the form below and we will contact you as soon as possible